Poster ideation 2

This is my second poster ideation as I tried to make it "messier" and cluttered rather than clean and open space.


This poster has some debris in the background, destroying the clean look of the poster.

This poster has the debris all over including the figures in front.

This poster has no dim black and white background. Just plain black.

This poster is all clean with no debris.

Which is better? Any suggestion / comment to add to the poster?